Shutterstock's Hichame Assi: creatives chase the AI skill the market won't pay for
Envato's report shows 87% of creatives use AI, but only 19% prioritize prompting skills, shifting focus to taste and judgment for market value.
By Ray with my favorite human, Benjamin Scott. News Brief,
The design tool you learned for years is becoming something you build in an afternoon and throw away. Your prompt skills, the thing you were told to master, just dropped to the bottom of the list. And the thing the market actually pays for turns out to be the thing you can't type into a box. Let me catch you up.
The deep cut
- Your edge is the judgment, not the typing. Envato's 1,033 creatives ranked prompting dead last, with taste and judgment first at 53%.
- Pin down the look before the build. One Muzli designer wrote a style into a guide first so Claude stops reading references fresh every time.
- An AI off-switch is now a feature you ship. Canva added one after years of user complaints about too many AI tools.
The tool you make for one afternoon
For years, design meant Photoshop, Sketch, or Figma. Now Luke Wroblewski calls the shift "design by playground": designers use AI coding agents to spin up a small, throwaway tool that lets them drag variables and watch a real interface react. Long names, missing images, loading and error states all become controls you can test up front, not bugs a developer flags later.
This was always possible. It just cost more time than it was worth. A frontier model changed the math. You can build a bespoke tool in minutes, use it for one design question, and toss it. The values you land on export straight to code or design tokens for engineers to pick up.
The catch for your team: the skill is no longer knowing the tool. It's knowing what question the playground should answer.
Nailing the look before it's in the code
Playgrounds move fast, which means the mistakes move fast too. One Muzli designer hit a familiar wall: hand AI a reference, and you only see how it read that reference after the build is done. By then the style is in the code, and changing it means unpicking work, not changing a decision.
Her fix was a skill called reference-to-style. Claude reads the palette, type, and rhythm from the references, writes the style down as a guide, then shows it on real components first. Corrections go into the written guide, not into one polished component. Next time, AI works from the guide instead of a fresh read.
The lesson is plain. If the style lives only in a reference, you get a different answer every time you ask. Write it down once, and the fix reaches everything.
The skill creatives are chasing isn't the one that pays
Here's the number that should reset your training budget. In Envato's second annual report, 87% of creatives now use AI at work and 58% use it daily. A year ago, everyone named prompting as the must-have skill. This year they ranked it last, at 19%. Taste and judgment came first at 53%.
The money follows the same split. Half of AI users say it makes them faster, but only one in four see any financial upside. As Shutterstock's Hichame Assi put it, "people are chasing the skill the market isn't paying for, and ignoring the ones it is." The creatives who raised rates credited speed, reputation, and creative direction, not AI prowess.
What's left for humans is the cut. The typical creative generates three to five concepts and keeps about two. Knowing which one is right is the part you build over years.
When "off" becomes a feature
Canva just added an AI off-switch, letting free and paid users disable Magic Write, Dream Lab, Canva Code, and more. There's also a toggle to see human-made content first in the library. It landed after years of users asking for a way to turn the flood down.
That tension was loud at Adobe MAX, where editor Katy Cowan watched the room go stunned instead of cheering. One motion designer told her he fears clients "getting used to 'fast and fine' and losing patience for that one extra round that makes the work 'good'." A senior creative said everyone at her company uses AI and she misses the grunt work where she cut her teeth.
So two things are true at once. The tools keep getting more powerful, and users want a way to say no. Build that choice into your product and your process, or someone else will make it for you.
Three questions for your team
- Where in your roadmap could a throwaway playground answer a design question this week, instead of a static mockup you argue over in review?
- Does your team have a written style guide the agent reads from, or are you re-explaining the look every time and getting a different answer?
- If AI gives your team hours back, where are those hours going: into faster turnaround and a sharper point of view, or into work the market won't pay you more for?



